Due to the fact that there are 42 clubs within the SPFL structure – from the Scottish Premiership to League Two – there are only 42 first team managerial roles within the SPFL set up.
With that in mind, there are a number of talented managers currently out of work.
I have picked out five managers who I believe could be an asset at varying levels of the SPFL should an opportunity arise in the near future:
Ian Murray
Ian Murray has built a solid reputation as a coach who can develop squads and extract value from limited resources.
The former Hibernian captain enjoyed a successful spell with Airdrieonians, guiding them to consistent promotion challenges, before moving to Raith Rovers in 2022.
His tenure in Kirkcaldy was impressive, as he helped Raith play an attractive, possession-based style and establish themselves as promotion contenders in the Championship.
Though currently unattached, Murray’s track record of developing young talent and implementing an organised, modern approach makes him a strong candidate for an SPFL return, particularly for clubs looking to steady the ship or challenge for promotion.
Kevin Thomson
Kevin Thomson is widely regarded as one of the brightest young coaches in Scottish football. The former Rangers and Hibs midfielder first made waves with Kelty Hearts, where he guided the Fife club to a League Two title in 2022, showcasing his ability to foster a winning mentality.
Thomson’s teams have been lauded for their attacking patterns of play and tactical discipline, traits that could translate well to higher divisions.
Thomson stepped down from Kelty shortly after their promotion, citing a desire for a new challenge, but he has yet to land a role that matches his ambitions. With his attention to detail and ability to inspire players, it’s only a matter of time before an SPFL club takes a chance on him.
Steven Naismith
Steven Naismith is a name synonymous with leadership, both on and off the pitch. The former Scotland international transitioned seamlessly into coaching, serving as a player-coach at Hearts before taking over as interim manager in April 2023 before going on to be named permanent manager two months later.
During his time in charge of the Jambos he led them to Europa Conference League qualification via a 3rd place finish in the Scottish Premiership.
Although, he departed Hearts in September 2024 as the club made the decision to appoint a more experienced head coach in Neil Critchley, Naismith remains a promising managerial prospect and had a win rate in Gorgie of 43%.
With his extensive knowledge of the Scottish game and natural leadership qualities, Naismith is well-suited for another opportunity to lead an SPFL side.
John Hughes
Few managers can match the charisma and experience of John Hughes, arguably better known by those within the Scottish game as ‘Yogi’.
Over the years, Hughes has built a reputation as a builder of teams, capable of inspiring players and fans alike. His crowning achievement came with Inverness Caledonian Thistle, where he won the Scottish Cup in 2015 and secured a top-three Premiership finish.
More recently, Hughes has taken on challenging roles, such as a successful stint at Scottish Premiership side Ross County and most recently with Dunfermline Athletic.
His ability to motivate players and desire to play front foot, attacking football would make him a valuable asset for clubs in need of fresh direction.
Robbie Horn
Robbie Horn may not have the profile of some of the others on this list, but his success at Bonnyrigg Rose speaks volumes about his potential. Horn led Bonnyrigg through a remarkable rise, guiding them from the East of Scotland League to the SPFL.
Under his leadership, the club consistently punched above their weight, combining a strong work ethic with a disciplined tactical setup.
Horn departed Bonnyrigg in 2024 after six years in charge of the club, but his achievements at Bonnyrigg were a testament to his managerial acumen. With a proven track record of building cohesive teams on modest budgets, Horn could be an ideal choice for SPFL clubs looking for a steady hand.
Featured image: CM Football Writing
Callum McFadden 