Scottish football thrives under managers who understand the unique demands of the SPFL. That means navigating promotion pushes, cup runs, relegation battles and maximising value from tight budgets.
Despite recent some recent setbacks, here are five managers whose leadership, ideas and ambition should remain firmly on clubs’ radar within each of the four SPFL divisions.
Robbie Neilson
“Neilson Scottish Cup” by www.theedinburghblog.co .uk is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
Robbie Neilson is one of the most recognisable managerial figures in Scottish football over the past decade. Rising through the ranks at Hearts, he took charge of the first team in 2014 and delivered immediate success. Neilson guided the club to the Scottish Championship title in his first season, restoring them to the Premiership before overseeing consistent top-flight finishes and European qualification.
His reputation has been built on organisational strength, defensive structure and the ability to work with limited resources, qualities SPFL clubs consistently seek.
After spells at MK Dons and Dundee United, and a stint overseas with Tampa Bay Rowdies that concluded last season, Neilson appears ready for a return to Scottish football.
Further enhancing his profile, he is currently working alongside Lee Johnson at SK Lommel, part of the City Football Group, who compete in the Belgian Challenger League. That exposure to a modern, multi-club environment only strengthens the case for another opportunity closer to home.
Rhys McCabe
At just 33, Rhys McCabe has already established himself as one of Scotland’s most promising young coaches. Following a solid playing career with Rangers, Dunfermline and clubs in the League of Ireland, McCabe was appointed player-manager of Airdrieonians in 2022. He led the club back to the Championship via the play-offs and delivered Scottish Challenge Cup success along the way.
His Airdrie side was widely praised for a progressive, possession-based approach, something not easily implemented in the lower leagues. While McCabe stepped down earlier this season for personal reasons, his ability to combine results with an attractive playing style highlighted genuine tactical acumen.
As more clubs prioritise development, identity and modern coaching principles, McCabe deserves another opportunity to show what he can build with time, stability and a greater budget.
John Rankin
John Rankin enjoyed a strong playing career and has transitioned steadily into management. After working within Hearts’ youth system, he stepped into senior management at Hamilton Academical during one of the most turbulent periods in the club’s history.
Despite severe financial and off-field issues, Rankin guided Accies to Scottish Challenge Cup success and immediate promotion back to the Championship in the 2023/24 season. His tenure was defined by calm leadership, squad unity and an ability to compete under extreme pressure.
Although he eventually resigned amid ongoing instability, Rankin’s work at Hamilton demonstrated qualities that many SPFL clubs value, particularly those operating under constraints. With stronger backing and a clearer structure, he looks well equipped to succeed again.
Michael Tidser
Michael Tidser’s introduction to senior management was challenging, with his short spell at Dunfermline Athletic ending after just 11 games during the 2024/25 season. However, that brief tenure should not overshadow the broader context of his coaching journey.
Tidser emerged at Kelty Hearts, where he played a key role in back-to-back promotions before stepping into a player-manager role. His leadership, connection with players and understanding of dressing-room dynamics were central to Kelty’s rapid rise through the divisions.
Early setbacks are common in management, and Tidser’s experience suggests there is more to come. Clubs with long-term planning and patience may view him as a coach capable of building culture and identity if given the right environment.
Kevin Thomson
Despite not managing for a few years since departing Kelty Hearts, Kevin Thomson is still regarded as one of the brightest young coaches in Scottish football.
The former Rangers and Hibs midfielder first made waves with Kelty Hearts, where he guided the Fife club to a League Two title in 2022, showcasing his ability to foster a winning mentality.
Thomson’s teams have been lauded for their attacking patterns of play and tactical discipline, traits that could translate well to higher divisions.
Thomson stepped down from Kelty shortly after their promotion, citing a desire for a new challenge, but he has yet to land a role that matches his ambitions. His continued time out of the managerial hot seat may suggest that he is finished with management and content with his other projects within the game.
Callum McFadden 